/
/
Is Andrew Garfield Joining Tulsa King?
Casting News · Tulsa King

Is Andrew Garfield Joining Tulsa King? What Stallone Said

Sylvester Stallone wants Andrew Garfield to play a villain in Tulsa King, but that is not the same as an official casting. Here is what he said, the role he imagined and where Season 5 stands.

FindCheapStreaming monkey mascot

Is Andrew Garfield joining Tulsa King?

Not officially. Sylvester Stallone has said he would like Andrew Garfield to play a villain in Tulsa King, but Garfield has not been announced as a new cast member. There is no confirmed character, contract or appearance date as of 8 November 2026.

Stallone shared the idea on The Rest Is Entertainment podcast, released on 5 November. Entertainment Weekly reported his comments on 8 November. It is an interesting possibility, especially with the show’s fifth season already in production, but for now it remains something Stallone wants rather than something Paramount+ has announced.

Garfield cast?No announcement
Stallone’s ideaA new villain
Next seasonSeason 5 confirmed
The distinction matters: Stallone expressing an interest in Garfield is not proof of negotiations, an audition or an accepted offer. Headlines suggesting he has already joined the series go further than the available evidence.

What did Sylvester Stallone actually say?

During an interview with Marina Hyde on The Rest Is Entertainment, Stallone recalled spending time with Garfield and being surprised by how well the two got on. That encounter gave him a casting idea for his Paramount+ crime drama.

“I’d love to have him as a villain in Tulsa King.”Sylvester Stallone, The Rest Is Entertainment, 5 November 2026

Stallone went on to describe the kind of opponent he had in mind: someone less physically imposing, more thoughtful and potentially linked to artificial intelligence. You can hear his comments in the original podcast episode.

What he didn’t say is just as important. There was no announcement that Garfield had read a script, been offered a part or signed up for Season 5. It sounded like a genuine creative idea rather than a formal casting reveal.

What kind of villain could Garfield play?

Rather than another gangster who simply wants to outmuscle Dwight Manfredi, Stallone imagined a villain who beats him by thinking differently. He even floated the possibility of an AI-driven threat.

That is what makes the suggestion more interesting to me than a normal celebrity casting rumour. Dwight is good at reading people, applying pressure and using old-school instincts to survive. A rival who is several moves ahead and doesn’t fight by the same rules could give the series a different sort of tension.

Garfield has also taken on dramatic roles that ask for subtlety as much as intensity, so I can see why Stallone pictured him as a character who would unsettle Dwight without relying on physical intimidation.

There is one big caveat: the AI angle is Stallone’s hypothetical idea, not a confirmed Season 5 storyline. There is no announced Garfield character or official synopsis involving an AI villain.

Why did Stallone think of Andrew Garfield?

The idea appears to have come from a real meeting rather than an established casting process. Stallone and Garfield recently appeared together on The Graham Norton Show. Garfield discussed his plans to portray magician Roy Horn, which prompted Stallone to share a story about meeting Siegfried and Roy years earlier.

Later, speaking on the podcast, Stallone said he hadn’t expected the two of them to connect so easily. He clearly came away thinking about what Garfield could bring to Tulsa King.

Entertainment Weekly also noted Garfield’s planned portrayal of Sam Altman in the film Artificial. That may explain why Stallone had technology on his mind, although Stallone did not say Garfield’s film role was the reason for his AI idea.

Could Andrew Garfield appear in Tulsa King Season 4 or Season 5?

Season 4 is already streaming on Paramount+, having premiered on 16 October 2026. The official cast guide names Stallone, Martin Starr, Jay Will, Gretchen Mol and other returning and new performers, but it does not list Garfield. There has been no announcement of a surprise appearance by him. See Paramount+’s Season 4 guide.

Season 5 is the more obvious place for a future casting, simply because it is the next announced instalment. Paramount+ renewed the show in October and says filming is underway in New York, where the story will return to Dwight’s old mafia territory.

But being possible is not the same as being planned. The studio has already announced several Season 5 additions, including Erik Palladino, Glenn Fleshler, Anthony Skordi and Nickola Shreli. Garfield isn’t among them. No Season 5 release date has been announced either. Read the official renewal update.

Season 4Already airing

Premiered 16 October 2026. Garfield is not in the published cast lineup.

Season 5Renewed and filming

Production is underway in New York. Garfield has not been announced for this season.

Andrew Garfield and Tulsa King: the timeline so far

Tulsa King is renewed for Season 5

Paramount+ confirms another season and the move to filming in New York, alongside several announced cast additions.

Season 4 premieres

The fourth season starts its weekly run on Paramount+. Garfield has no announced role in its official cast information.

Stallone’s podcast interview is released

Stallone talks about his friendly encounter with Garfield and describes an idea for a different kind of villain.

The casting idea makes headlines

Entertainment Weekly reports Stallone’s comments. There is still no official announcement from Paramount+ or Garfield.

Would Andrew Garfield be a good fit? My take

I actually like this idea. Tulsa King has plenty of characters who can threaten Dwight with violence, but that is not the only way to make a villain intimidating. Someone calm, calculated and difficult to read could be far more interesting than another man turning up with a bigger crew.

What I especially like is that Stallone seems to be thinking about how a different actor would change the story, rather than just chasing a famous face for publicity. If Garfield ever does join, I’d rather see him given a proper role with time to develop than a brief cameo that exists only for headlines.

Still, I wouldn’t start calling this a done deal. Until Garfield or Paramount+ confirms something, it is simply a casting idea from the show’s biggest star. A good idea, in my view, but only an idea.

FindCheapStreaming monkey mascot

The latest answer

Andrew Garfield has not been confirmed for Tulsa King. Sylvester Stallone wants him to play a clever, potentially AI-driven villain. Season 5 is going ahead, but no Garfield casting announcement has been made as of 8 November 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is Andrew Garfield joining Tulsa King?

Not officially. Sylvester Stallone said he would like Garfield to play a villain, but no casting agreement or role has been announced as of 8 November 2026.

Did Sylvester Stallone ask Andrew Garfield to join Tulsa King?

Stallone publicly said he would love to have Garfield as a villain. He did not say that a formal offer had been made or accepted.

What character would Andrew Garfield play in Tulsa King?

No character exists as an announced Garfield role. Stallone imagined a thoughtful, perhaps AI-driven antagonist, but this was an idea rather than a confirmed plotline.

Is Andrew Garfield in Tulsa King Season 4?

No official Season 4 cast announcement includes Andrew Garfield. Season 4 began streaming on Paramount+ on 16 October 2026.

Could Andrew Garfield appear in Tulsa King Season 5?

It is possible in principle, but there has been no casting confirmation. Season 5 is renewed and filming in New York, with several different new series regulars already announced.

Has Tulsa King been renewed for Season 5?

Yes. Paramount+ confirmed a fifth season in October 2026, and production began in New York. No premiere date has been announced.

Where can I watch Tulsa King in the UK?

Tulsa King streams on Paramount+ in the UK. Availability and subscription offers can change, so check the platform for the current episode list.