Can Orcs Be Good in The Rings of Power? Marnûkh’s Season 3 Choice
Marnûkh turns against Sauron in Season 3, but does that make him good? Adar, Glüg and Tolkien’s writings reveal why the answer is more complicated.

Yes, Orcs can make good choices in The Rings of Power, and Season 3 finally puts that possibility to the test through Marnûkh. The Orc turns against Sauron, risks entering Gundabad with Galadriel and Arondir, and helps release prisoners. None of that erases his violent past. It does, however, make it harder to say that an Orc can only serve evil.
Marnûkh does more than complain about Sauron’s rule. He hands the Elves information that could stop the One Ring, leads them into a dangerous Orc fortress and helps them escape. Arondir, who distrusts him almost to the end, has reason to reconsider. That is the clearest test of Orc free will the series has offered so far.
Major spoilers ahead: this article covers the first four episodes of Season 3, released on Prime Video on 11 November 2026, including the events at Gundabad.
Did Tolkien think Orcs could be redeemed?
Tolkien never gave us a neat scene in which an Orc renounces evil and lives happily among the Elves. In The Lord of the Rings, Orcs are usually brutal soldiers, raiders and servants of dark powers. Yet the question of whether they are incapable of good troubled him.
In his draft Letter 153 to Peter Hastings, Tolkien wrestled with the moral status of Orcs rather than declaring them irredeemably wicked. In Letter 269 to W. H. Auden, he returned to the idea that Orcs were not evil in their origin. The letters do not provide a completed Orc redemption story. They do suggest that being corrupted is different from being created evil.
Evil corrupts; it does not truly create
Morgoth twists what already exists. That leaves an uncomfortable question about the remaining will and moral responsibility of the people he corrupts.
Good Orcs are not a familiar sight
Orcs argue with their masters and each other, but disobedience and self-interest are not the same as kindness or redemption.
That is why the answer cannot be a simple claim that Tolkien either approved of heroic Orcs or ruled them out entirely. His writings allow for pity and moral choice even though his major narratives rarely show those possibilities being realised. Letter 269 and the discussion of Orc origins are useful starting points for the distinction.
Were Orcs once Elves, or were they always evil?
One of the most familiar explanations in The Silmarillion is that Morgoth captured and corrupted Elves in the earliest days of Middle-earth. The series draws on that idea with Adar, an ancient being whose Elven origins have been damaged by Morgoth’s cruelty. But Tolkien did not settle permanently on a single explanation of where every Orc came from.
The corrupted-Elves tradition
Morgoth distorts captives rather than bringing a wholly new people into existence through his own power.
Other origins remain possible
He reconsidered the relationship between Orcs and Men, and what their origin meant for free will.
Adar puts a face to corruption
The television story gives the Orcs a father figure who remembers what was done to him and wants his children to live free of Sauron.
The origin question matters because sympathy for a damaged person is not the same as absolving everything they do. An Orc can have suffered terribly and still be responsible for cruelty. Season 3 is interested in whether an Orc can break that pattern.
Was Adar a good Orc, or simply a different kind of villain?
Adar’s dream was easy to understand, even when his methods were impossible to defend. He wanted a homeland where the Uruk could raise their children instead of serving one dark master after another. His anger at Sauron came from knowing what that servitude cost them. But he also enslaved people, oversaw the making of Mordor and sent his followers into the slaughter at Eregion.
The Season 2 finale gives his story its most painful moment. After Nenya restores his Elven appearance, he offers Galadriel the possibility of peace. It lasts only a moment before the Orcs turn on him and kill him. Sauron gains the army Adar had tried to keep out of his hands.
Why Adar deserves sympathy
He recognises the Orcs as people with families, names and a right to exist without a master.
Why that does not make him innocent
He accepts immense suffering, including among his own followers, as the price of protecting their future.
Marnûkh’s story picks up where that tragedy ends. Instead of promising freedom while marching into another war, he acts against Sauron’s immediate interests. His motives are not entirely selfless, but his choices give Adar’s lost hope new life.
Why did The Rings of Power show an Orc family?
The scene of Glüg with his partner and child in Season 2 was more than a surprising image. It gave a name and a home life to someone who would otherwise look like another soldier in Adar’s ranks. Glüg fears that the war against Sauron will destroy the people Adar claims to protect.
Tolkien did not treat Orcs as creatures who simply appeared from nowhere. They reproduced, and the series makes that fact intimate by showing parents with a baby. The scene does not prove Orcs are harmless. It shows what they themselves have to lose.
That difference becomes crucial when Marnûkh explains why he is abandoning Sauron in Season 3. He remembers Adar’s hope of peace and sees what constant warfare is doing to the Uruk. His decision has a political motive as well as a personal one: he does not want his people spent as disposable troops.
Why did Glüg betray Adar if he wanted peace?
Glüg’s fear for his family makes his betrayal understandable, but not good. He sees Adar’s campaign consuming Orc lives without bringing the peace they were promised. When Sauron finds that division, he turns it into an opportunity. Glüg and the others kill Adar, giving Sauron control of the surviving army.
Another war with no end
He believes Adar has begun sacrificing the very Orcs whose survival is supposed to justify the fighting.
A worse master takes over
By turning against Adar, the Orcs help Sauron establish precisely the domination their former leader feared.
That is the contrast with Marnûkh. Both resist the direction in which their people are being taken, but Glüg’s choice hands power to Sauron. Marnûkh’s decision, at least through Episode 4, threatens Sauron’s plan. It is not enough to want the right outcome; the action taken to reach it matters.
Can an Orc truly choose to oppose Sauron?
Season 3 answers that question more clearly than the first two seasons did. Marnûkh begins as a general in Sauron’s army and understands how the Dark Lord works. In Episode 1, he raises the awkward problem that Sauron may have burned the knowledge he needs to master the Elven Rings when he destroyed Celebrimbor’s records. Soon afterwards, he gives himself up to the Dwarves with information he says can change the war.
When he reaches Galadriel and Arondir, he reveals Sauron’s intention to forge a single ruling Ring. He also tells them that Maitalle, an Elven-smith who might hold useful knowledge, is a prisoner in Gundabad. What follows is not instant friendship. Arondir looks for a trap in nearly everything Marnûkh says, and he has good reason to be wary of an Orc who once served Sauron.
He wants the Uruk to survive
Stopping Sauron’s war may protect Marnûkh and his people from being used until nothing remains.
He puts himself at risk for others
Going into Gundabad, helping the Elves and unleashing the prisoners exposes him to danger that obedience would have avoided.
Marnûkh is still abrasive and sometimes cruel. On the road he needles Arondir about Bronwyn, a taunt that nearly ends their uneasy alliance. But his warning about Sauron’s forces proves accurate, and the Elves have to judge him by more than his species or his history.
What does Marnûkh actually do in Season 3?
Marnûkh, played by Adam Young, makes his choices over four episodes rather than in a single speech. The result is more convincing because the Elves never entirely relax around him. Even when the mission is moving forward, his manner keeps testing their trust.
He questions Sauron
He challenges the loss of Celebrimbor’s knowledge and later surrenders with information he believes could stop the Dark Lord.
He leads the Elves north
Galadriel and Arondir learn about the One Ring and Maitalle. On the journey to Gundabad, his warnings prove credible even as Arondir continues to doubt him.
He turns the prison against its guards
He gets the Elves inside under the pretence of being their captor, helps them fight their way through and releases other prisoners to create an escape route.
The mission does not end with the victory anyone expected. Maitalle is already dead when they find her cell. They discover Celeborn alive instead, and Galadriel’s reunion with her husband is cut short when Sauron and his Ring-servants arrive. As the group tries to flee, Arondir moves to help Marnûkh when he is knocked down in the fighting.
Then the masked Ring-servant is revealed as Theo. Sauron orders him to kill Arondir, and Theo obeys. It is a devastating ending to Arondir’s attempt to find the boy he helped raise. Marnûkh’s own ultimate fate is not clearly settled by the end of Episode 4, so he should not yet be described as dead or fully redeemed.
For the wider prison-break story, see our Gundabad Episode 4 explanation. The scenes also give the season an uncomfortable contrast: the Orc chooses to help, while a young Man under Sauron’s influence carries out his order to kill.
So, can Orcs be good in The Rings of Power?
Yes. Season 3 shows that an Orc can choose to do good even after serving evil. Marnûkh does not become gentle or morally spotless. He remains someone who has participated in Sauron’s world of violence. But he chooses to risk his own safety, warn the Elves and help people Sauron would rather keep imprisoned.
That matters more than the fact that Glüg has a family or Adar dreams of peace. Those things make the Orcs understandable. Marnûkh’s actions make the question of their moral freedom harder to dismiss. By the time the group reaches Gundabad, the most straightforwardly compassionate choice is not always made by the character anyone expected.
Tolkien left the deeper question open across his writings, while the television adaptation is taking a more visible step towards answering it. The season is only halfway through as of 11 November 2026, with Episodes 5–6 due on 18 November and the final two on 25 November. Whether Marnûkh survives, changes further or falls back into cruelty remains part of the story still to come.
Frequently asked questions
Can Orcs be good in Tolkien’s books?
Tolkien did not write a prominent fully redeemed Orc in The Lord of the Rings, but his letters and later notes question the idea that Orcs were evil in their very origin or automatically beyond every hope of mercy.
Is Marnûkh a good Orc in Season 3?
Marnûkh makes several good choices: he warns Galadriel about the One Ring, helps her and Arondir enter Gundabad, and frees prisoners. His motives include protecting the Uruk, and his violent past has not been erased.
Does Marnûkh betray Sauron?
Yes. He defects from Sauron’s forces and helps the Elves act against the Dark Lord’s plan to forge the One Ring.
Does Marnûkh die in Episode 4?
His death is not established clearly in the first four episodes. He is knocked down during the Gundabad escape, but his final fate remains unresolved as of 11 November 2026.
Was Adar a good Orc?
Adar wanted freedom and a homeland for the Uruk, but he also ordered brutal campaigns and sacrifices. He is a tragic, morally conflicted figure rather than an uncomplicated hero.
Why did Glüg betray Adar?
Glüg feared Adar’s war would destroy the Orc families he hoped to protect. Sauron exploited that discontent, and the betrayal placed the Uruk under Sauron’s control.
Are Orc women and babies part of Tolkien’s lore?
Tolkien described Orcs as reproducing. Glüg’s particular partner and child are characters introduced by the television series.
Were Orcs originally Elves?
The corrupted-Elves account is prominent in The Silmarillion, and the series draws on it for Adar. Tolkien also explored other explanations and did not settle every detail of Orc origins.
Sources and further reading
- J.R.R. Tolkien — The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, draft Letter 153 to Peter Hastings and Letter 269 to W. H. Auden
- J.R.R. Tolkien — The Silmarillion, “Of the Coming of the Elves and the Captivity of Melkor”; Morgoth’s Ring, “Myths Transformed”
- Tolkien Gateway — Tolkien’s comments on Orcs and their origin
- Tolkien Gateway — the changing origins of Orcs
- TV Insider — the Orc family and Glüg in Season 2
- Winter Is Coming — Season 3, Episode 1, “Marnûkh” (11 November 2026)
- TVLine — Season 3, Episode 2, “Istar” (11 November 2026)
- TVLine — Season 3, Episode 3, “The Secret Fire” (11 November 2026)
- TVLine — Season 3, Episode 4, “Gundabad” (11 November 2026)
- Prime Video — official Season 3 release schedule
